Initially, the assessment of the carcasses was 4* based solely on my impressions of the tester, but when I decided to look at the price, then lowered to 3*.
Mascara is not the most, of course, bad, but for 2500 rubles (price of Ile de Beaute), you can buy something much better.
And my final result:
But! Red the price of this mascara - 1200-1500 rubles without discounts, taking into account margins for luxury name Shiseido. Solely due to high prices - 3 stars, but the quality is normal, I would rate at 3.5.